Our delectable cookies

Kelly's Cookies: A Sweet Delight

Welcome to Kelly's Cookies, where every bite is a delightful experience! Our cookies are made from the finest ingredients, ensuring that each treat is not only delicious but also crafted with love. Whether you crave classic chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, or something more adventurous like salted caramel pecan, we have a flavor to satisfy every sweet tooth. At Kelly's Cookies, we believe in the power of homemade goodness. Each batch is baked fresh daily, providing you with the warm, comforting taste of cookies just like Grandma used to make. Perfect for sharing with friends and family or indulging in a quiet moment to yourself, our cookies are the perfect accompaniment to your favorite beverage. Explore our range of flavors and find your new favorite cookie today!

Banana Pudding Cookies

$2.00

Indulge in pure, nostalgic bliss. Crafted in small batches, these cookies feature a decadent pudding-infused dough that stays phenomenally soft and pillowy for days. Every single cookie is loaded with rich, sweet real banana flavor, velvety vanilla cream notes, and a satisfying textural crunch from crushed toasted wafers. Deeply buttery, fragrant, and topped with a whole vanilla wafer for a picture-perfect finish.

See details

Brownie Cookies

$2.00

Say hello to the Brownie Cookie! We took the rich, gooey, fudgy center of a homemade brownie and packed it into a thick, chewy cookie. They are intensely chocolatey, perfectly sweet, and absolutely loaded with extra pockets of melted chocolate chips. Guaranteed to satisfy your sweet tooth in just one bite.

See details

Chocolate Pie Cookies

$2.00

These are not "just cookies"—they are decadent, individual silk pies disguised as a handheld luxury. We start with a deeply fudgy, dark chocolate cookie base that has the perfect cake-to-chew ratio. The center is piled high with a velvety, cool chocolate filling, then finished with a cloud of fresh whipped cream and elegant chocolate curls. It is pure, nostalgic dessert heaven in every single bite.

See details

Oatmeal Raisin

$2.00

A sophisticated, deeply comforting tribute to a bakery classic. Made in small batches using sweet creamery butter, toasted whole oats, and a complex blend of warm baking spices. To guarantee absolute moisture, our premium raisins are plumped before baking, ensuring they stay incredibly tender and juicy. It features a thick, bend-don't-break chewy center with lightly crisped, golden-toasted edges.

See details

Tagalongs

$2.00

Satisfy your deepest cravings with the absolute perfect harmony of chocolate and peanut butter. Every single bite delivers a flawless contrast of textures: a light, golden-crisp vanilla cookie base topped with a thick, decadent layer of velvety-smooth, real roasted peanut butter. It is completely enrobed in a rich, silky chocolaty coating that melts perfectly the moment you take a bite.

See details

SnickerDoodle

$2.00

A timeless favorite perfected. Our snickerdoodle features an incredibly plush, pillowy-soft center with a subtle, signature tang that sets it apart from a standard sugar cookie. Generously hand-rolled in a pristine blend of fragrant Korintje cinnamon and pure cane sugar, it bakes up with a beautifully crackled exterior that delivers pure, nostalgic warmth in every bite.

See details

Strawberry Cheesecake cookies

$2.00

I can also do it with other flavors 

Can’t decide between cookies or cake? Have both! These massive cookies taste exactly like a slice of homemade strawberry cheesecake

See details

Peanut Butter and Jelly Thumb Prints Cookies

$2.00

It can be made with what ever jelly you like.

Your favorite childhood comfort food, transformed into an elegant, bite-sized gourmet treat. We take a rich, melt-in-your-mouth peanut butter cookie base and nestle a brilliant jewel of sweet, vibrant raspberry jam right in the center. It is the ultimate nostalgic flavor duo, perfected for the modern palate.

See details

Butter

$1.16

Classic, golden-baked butter cookies made the old-fashioned way. Incredibly rich, perfectly sweet, and crafted with 100% real cream butter. They are melt-in-your-mouth soft with just the right amount of delicate snap.

See details

Short Bread

$1.16

Classic Scottish-style shortbread crafted with just four simple ingredients. Incredibly rich, perfectly sweet, and baked to a delicate pale gold. They deliver a satisfyingly crisp snap that instantly dissolves into a smooth, melt-in-your-mouth finish.

See details

Chocolate Chip

$1.16

Crispy on the very edges, thick and ultra-gooey in the center. Our signature chocolate chip cookies are loaded to the absolute brim with melting pools of premium semi-sweet chocolate. Baked fresh daily so every bite is pure comfort.

See details

Peanut Butter Cookies

$1.16

The ultimate nostalgic comfort food, perfected. We blend rich, slow-roasted creamy peanut butter with deep dark brown sugar to create a cookie that is decadently dense and chewy on the inside, with perfectly crisp, golden-brown edges.

See details

Thin Mint

$1.16

The ultimate chocolate-mint obsession. Delightfully light and intensely refreshing, these cookies feature a crisp, deeply chocolatey wafer infused with natural peppermint oil. Each one is fully submerged in a velvety smooth dark chocolate shell for that signature, clean snap.

See details

Sugar

$1.16

The ultimate classic sugar cookie, elevated. Baked to be incredibly soft, thick, and pillowy with a beautifully chewy center. Infused with pure vanilla bean and real sweet-cream butter.

See details